This was the first time I have ordered from Romeo's. The delivery guy was really nice, the food was amazing! Their L&B pie is probably the best on the island, portions are plentiful. I am fussy with sauce, and these folks have an awesome sauce. Definitely will order from them again (a lot).
Honest, hardworking people that run this neighborhood staple for decades now. Lost my wallet in the parking lot and not only they kept it for me but even called so i knew where to find it! The food itself was fresh from the oven and reasonably priced Will keep going back.
Amazing service- the owners and the delivery driver went above and beyond to correct an order error that was completely my fault. Every time I have ordered in the past has been great. Clearly, this mom and pop shop really cares about there customers. Ty Elena
The Delivery was Fast and Hot and the Young Man was so Nice! Margherita Pie was out of the World and the Baked Calzone was Perfect ! Thank you so Much Romeos! Romeos Pizzeria And Restaurant has such Delish Food... a must for your Grubhub list!
We LOVE to get pizza from Romeo's! We have known Tony since his Brooklyn days, and always enjoy his cooking! The business is very clean, and it truly is a family oriented atmosphere! We are here at least once a week!
Reviews from Seamless.com
Ive been absolutely bewildered at how hard it is to find a good pie out in Staten Island and was starting to think that maybe Staten Island just doesnt have good pizza. I randomly picked Romeos because it had a cheesesteak(perfectly acceptable pizzeria cheesesteak) on the menu and also because the Vodka Roll(not bad at all, could have used mozzarella or more mozzarella but still tasty) sounded interesting. I decided to order a personal pie on whim because I had a discount because it was my first order and figured why not take another shot at finding a pizza worth eating on the other side of the Verrazano and it wound up being an excellent pie. Thumbs up on the crust, the sauce, the cheese, everything. Solid delivery experience as well.
Whenever I get a craving for Italian food, this is my go-to! Their penne vodka lunch is a great value in my opinion and the garlic bread is everything I want in a garlic bread: garlic & buttery soft inside with a nice crisp outside (so eat it while it's hot!) served with some sort of tomato or marinara sauce. They also have a side of bread for you to really relish the pasta sauce. Their espresso is also really delicious!
Pasta with garlic and oil was excellent. Zeppoles, chocolate mousse cake and pizza were great. Food came on time and order was correct. First time ordering from here as I just moved to the neighborhood but will be ordering a lot more. Joe M
Delivery was ahead of schedule, food was tasty and still hot. Delivery person was pleasant, all around a good experience.
Ordered vodka Pizza. OMG! It was delicious! My parents enjoyed it too. Will definitely order from them again soon.